Last night I made chili, and having soaked too many beans, I realized I would need to make two batches. I took the opportunity to experiment a little by slightly varying the two pots, and then I had the grand idea to actually document what I did.
The ingredient lists:
| Small Batch | Large Batch |
|
2 1/4 c cooked beans 1 small yellow onion, diced 1 large clove garlic, minced 1 small celery stick, chopped 2 1/2 tbsp tomato paste w/ 1 c water 1/2 tbsp cumin-pepper mix* 1 small dried chipotle pepper 1/4 tbsp ground peppercorns 1 1/4 c hot water 1 1/2 c crushed tomatoes 2 tbsp brewed coffee 1 tbsp turbinado sugar salt to taste |
3 3/4 c cooked beans 2 small yellow onions, diced 2 large cloves garlic, minced 1 medium celery stick, chopped 1 small carrot, chopped 5 tbsp tomato paste w/ 1 1/4 c water 3/4 tbsp cumin-pepper mix* 1 medium dried chipotle pepper 1/4 stick cinnamon 1/4 tbsp ground peppercorns 2 c hot water 3 tbsp coffee 1 1/2 c tomatoes salt to taste |
* cumin-pepper mix: 1 tbsp cumin seeds + 4 dried chili peppers. Grind together.
A note about cooking temperatures: I don’t know what to tell you! I cook with cast iron pots and skillets, which means that I cook at medium heat. This will vary according to the kind of pot used, but generally the heat should not be so high that things are burning. :-}
The cooking process:
- Heat some oil. Enough for frying the spices and onions and garlic. When the oil is hot, add the cumin-pepper mix, chipotle pepper, and cinnamon (if applicable). When you can smell the spices (just a few seconds)…
- Add onion and garlic and a pinch of salt. Stir often. Cook until the onions are starting to brown.
- Mix tomato paste and water to … a paste. Add to pot. Add peppercorns. Stir often and add water if the mixture gets too dry or is sticking to the bottom of the pot. Cook for about five minutes.
- Add the hot water, beans, celery, and carrots (if applicable). When it seems like this mixture has gotten hot (a few minutes), add the crushed tomatoes, coffee, and sugar (if applicable). Add some salt (1 teaspoon?).
- Bring this mixture to a simmer – cover if necessary. Adjust heat to maintain a simmer with the pot mostly covered. Stir occasionally. When stirring, check for consistency. If it’s getting too thick, add some hot water, but keep in mind that it should be reducing, slowly. At the end of an hour, my pots had both reduced about an inch or so. If the chili is reducing faster than that, the heat is probably too high, or it should be more covered. Simmer for about an hour.
- If the chili is getting too thick at this point — that is, if it looks like it’s going to turn into pasty bean dip if it simmers for another half hour — add some water, about a cup. Also this is a good point to taste for salt and add as needed. Also taste for heat/spice and add if needed (paprika or cayenne are good choices).
- Simmer for another half hour, still partially covered. Done!
The verdict: I liked the smaller batch better. It was spicier, a little sweeter (obviously), and just generally had a richer flavor. I couldn’t taste the cinnamon at all in the larger batch.











